| Year | Pos | Sel | Player | Team |
| 2012 | QB | 1 | Aaron Rodgers | MBB |
| 2012 | QB | 2 | Matthew Stafford | LCZ |
| 2012 | QB | 3 | Drew Brees | E4E |
| 2012 | QB | 4 | Cam Newton | DGK |
| 2012 | RB | 5 | Lesean Mccoy | GSQ |
| 2012 | QB | 6 | Tom Brady | ARM |
| 2012 | RB | 7 | Ray Rice | RAC |
| 2012 | QB | 8 | Matt Ryan | THR |
| 2012 | RB | 9 | Arian Foster | DTD |
| 2012 | QB | 10 | Andrew Luck | FVH |
| 2012 | WR | 11 | Calvin Johnon | FVH |
| 2012 | QB | 12 | Eli Manning | DTD |
| 2012 | TE | 13 | Jimmie Graham | THR |
| 2012 | RB | 14 | Ryan Matthews | RAC |
| 2012 | TE | 15 | Rob Gronkowski | ARM |
| 2012 | RB | 16 | Trent Richardson | GSQ |
| 2012 | RB | 17 | Darren McFadden | DGK |
| 2012 | RB | 18 | Maurice Jones-Drew | E4E |
| 2012 | QB | 19 | Phillip Rivers | LCZ |
| 2012 | WR | 20 | AJ Green | MBB |
| 2012 | RB | 21 | Adrian Peterson | MBB |
| 2012 | WR | 22 | Larry Fitzgerald | LCZ |
| 2012 | QB | 23 | Matt Schaub | E4E |
| 2012 | RB | 24 | Matt Forte | DGK |
| 2012 | RB | 25 | Chris Johnson | GSQ |
| 2012 | QB | 26 | Tony Romo | ARM |
| 2012 | WR | 27 | Dez Bryant | RAC |
| 2012 | WR | 28 | Julio Jones | THR |
| 2012 | RB | 29 | Jamal Charles | DTD |
| 2012 | QB | 30 | Robert Griffin III | FVH |
| 2012 | WR | 31 | Hakeem Nicks | FVH |
| 2012 | QB | 32 | Jay Cutler | DTD |
| 2012 | QB | 33 | Sam Bradford | THR |
| 2012 | WR | 34 | Brandon Marshall | RAC |
| 2012 | RB | 35 | Demarco Murray | ARM |
| 2012 | QB | 36 | Michael Vick | GSQ |
| 2012 | QB | 37 | Alex Smtih | DGK |
| 2012 | WR | 38 | Jordy Nelson | E4E |
| 2012 | WR | 39 | Greg Jennings | LCZ |
| 2012 | QB | 40 | Josh Freeman | MBB |
| 2012 | WR | 41 | Andre Johnson | MBB |
| 2012 | WR | 42 | Mike Wallace | LCZ |
| 2012 | RB | 43 | Marshawn Lynch | E4E |
| 2012 | WR | 44 | Percy Harvin | DGK |
| 2012 | WR | 45 | Victor Cruz | GSQ |
| 2012 | WR | 46 | Miles Austin | ARM |
| 2012 | QB | 47 | Joe Flacco | RAC |
| 2012 | RB | 48 | Mark Ingram | THR |
| 2012 | WR | 49 | Marques Colston | DTD |
| 2012 | RB | 50 | Doug Martin | FVH |
| 2012 | WR | 51 | Justin Blackmon | FVH |
| 2012 | RB | 52 | Ahmad Bradshaw | DTD |
| 2012 | WR | 53 | Dem Thomas | THR |
| 2012 | QB | 54 | Peyton Manning | RAC |
| 2012 | RB | 55 | Rashard Mendy | ARM |
| 2012 | QB | 56 | Ben Roethlisberger | GSQ |
| 2012 | QB | 57 | Andy Dalton | DGK |
| 2012 | WR | 58 | Wes Welker | E4E |
| 2012 | WR | 59 | Kenny Britt | LCZ |
| 2012 | WR | 60 | Roddy White | MBB |
| 2012 | QB | 61 | Jake Locker | MBB |
| 2012 | RB | 62 | Jonathon Stewart | LCZ |
| 2012 | WR | 63 | Vincent Jackson | E4E |
| 2012 | WR | 64 | Dwayne Bowe | DGK |
| 2012 | WR | 65 | Steve Smith | GSQ |
| 2012 | RB | 66 | Darren Sproles | ARM |
| 2012 | TE | 67 | Jermichael Finley | RAC |
| 2012 | WR | 68 | Jeremy Maclin | THR |
| 2012 | TE | 69 | Vernon Davis | DTD |
| 2012 | RB | 70 | CJ Spiller | FVH |
| 2012 | RB | 71 | Beanie Wells | FVH |
| 2012 | WR | 72 | Stevie Johnson | DTD |
| 2012 | RB | 73 | Steven Jackson | THR |
| 2012 | WR | 74 | Eric Decker | RAC |
| 2012 | WR | 75 | Malcolm Floyd | ARM |
| 2012 | WR | 76 | Torrey Smith | GSQ |
| 2012 | TE | 77 | Aaron Hernandez | DGK |
| 2012 | RB | 78 | David Wilson | E4E |
| 2012 | RB | 79 | Ben Jarvis Ellis | LCZ |
| 2012 | WR | 80 | Stephen Hill | MBB |
| 2012 | WR | 81 | Antonio Brown | MBB |
| 2012 | QB | 82 | Christian Ponder | LCZ |
| 2012 | RB | 83 | Frank Gore | E4E |
| 2012 | WR | 84 | Michael Floyd | DGK |
| 2012 | WR | 85 | Greg Little | GSQ |
| 2012 | WR | 86 | Pierre Garcon | ARM |
| 2012 | TE | 87 | Antonio Gates | RAC |
| 2012 | RB | 88 | Isaiah Pead | THR |
| 2012 | WR | 89 | Desean Jackson | DTD |
| 2012 | QB | 90 | Matt Flynn | FVH |
| 2012 | WR | 91 | Sidney Rice | FVH |
| 2012 | RB | 92 | Roy Helu | DTD |
| 2012 | RB | 93 | James Starks | THR |
| 2012 | RB | 94 | Michael Turner | RAC |
| 2012 | QB | 95 | Kevin Kolb | ARM |
| 2012 | TE | 96 | Brandon Pettigrew | GSQ |
| 2012 | WR | 97 | Michael Crabtree | DGK |
| 2012 | TE | 98 | Jason Witten | E4E |
| 2012 | RB | 99 | Ben Tate | LCZ |
| 2012 | RB | 100 | Shonn Greene | MBB |
| 2012 | QB | 101 | Ryan Tannehill | MBB |
| 2012 | RB | 102 | Jermaine Gresham | LCZ |
| 2012 | RB | 103 | LaMichael James | E4E |
| 2012 | RB | 104 | Shane Vereen | DGK |
| 2012 | QB | 105 | Brandon Weeden | GSQ |
| 2012 | WR | 106 | Brandon Lloyd | ARM |
| 2012 | WR | 107 | Reggie Wayne | RAC |
| 2012 | WR | 108 | Mike Williams | THR |
| 2012 | TE | 109 | Fred Davis | DTD |
| 2012 | TE | 110 | Jared Cook | FVH |
| 2012 | RB | 111 | Kendell Hunter | FVH |
| 2012 | QB | 112 | Mark Sanchez | DTD |
| 2012 | QB | 113 | Blaine Gabbert | THR |
| 2012 | D | 114 | Bears D | RAC |
| 2012 | RB | 115 | Reggie Bush | ARM |
| 2012 | D | 116 | 49ers D | GSQ |
| 2012 | RB | 117 | Michael Bush | DGK |
| 2012 | WR | 118 | Santonio Holmes | E4E |
| 2012 | WR | 119 | Alshon Jeffrey | LCZ |
| 2012 | TE | 120 | Coby Fleener | MBB |
| 2012 | RB | 121 | Lamar Miller | MBB |
| 2012 | RB | 122 | Donald Brown | LCZ |
| 2012 | QB | 123 | Ryan Fitzpatrick | E4E |
| 2012 | RB | 124 | Steven Ridley | DGK |
| 2012 | QB | 125 | Carson Palmer | GSQ |
| 2012 | TE | 126 | Kyle Rudolph | ARM |
| 2012 | QB | 127 | Brock Osweiler | RAC |
| 2012 | WR | 128 | Brian Quick | THR |
| 2012 | WR | 129 | Robert Meachem | DTD |
| 2012 | QB | 130 | Matt Cassel | FVH |
| 2012 | RB | 131 | Mikel Leshoure | FVH |
| 2012 | QB | 132 | Colin Kaepernick | DTD |
| 2012 | WR | 133 | Davonne Bess | THR |
| 2012 | RB | 134 | Jahvid Best | RAC |
| 2012 | RB | 135 | Daniel Thomas | ARM |
| 2012 | WR | 136 | Muhamed Sanu | GSQ |
| 2012 | RB | 137 | Ryan Williams | DGK |
| 2012 | D | 138 | Ravens Defense | E4E |
| 2012 | RB | 139 | Willis Mcgahee | LCZ |
| 2012 | WR | 140 | Randall Cobb | MBB |
| 2012 | RB | 141 | Knowshon Moreno | MBB |
| 2012 | WR | 142 | Darius Heyward-Bey | LCZ |
| 2012 | RB | 143 | Isaac Redman | E4E |
| 2012 | WR | 144 | Jon Baldwin | DGK |
| 2012 | TE | 145 | Kellen Winslow Jr | GSQ |
| 2012 | QB | 146 | John Skelton | ARM |
| 2012 | QB | 147 | Ryan Mallet | RAC |
| 2012 | WR | 148 | Kendell Wright | THR |
| 2012 | WR | 149 | Titus Young | DTD |
| 2012 | RB | 150 | Chris Polk | FVH |
| 2012 | TE | 151 | Julius Thomas | FVH |
| 2012 | WR | 152 | Reuben Randle | DTD |
| 2012 | QB | 153 | Nick Foles | THR |
| 2012 | WR | 154 | Vincent Brown | RAC |
| 2012 | D | 155 | Pittsburgh D | ARM |
| 2012 | RB | 156 | Fred Jackson | GSQ |
| 2012 | RB | 157 | Jaquizz Rodgers | DGK |
| 2012 | TE | 158 | Ed Dickson | E4E |
| 2012 | WR | 159 | LaMichael James | LCZ |
| 2012 | RB | 160 | Ronnie Hillman | MBB |
| 2012 | RB | 161 | Deangelo Williams | MBB |
| 2012 | TE | 162 | Lance Kendricks | LCZ |
| 2012 | WR | 163 | Golden Tate | E4E |
| 2012 | WR | 164 | Lance Moore | DGK |
| 2012 | QB | 165 | Kirk Cousins | GSQ |
| 2012 | TE | 166 | Ladarius Green | ARM |
| 2012 | WR | 167 | Austin Collie | RAC |
| 2012 | WR | 168 | Brandon LaFell | THR |
| 2012 | RB | 169 | Robert Turbin | DTD |
| 2012 | WR | 170 | Juron Criner | FVH |
| 2012 | QB | 171 | Tyrod Taylor | FVH |
| 2012 | D | 172 | Lions D | DTD |
| 2012 | WR | 173 | Nick Toon | THR |
| 2012 | RB | 174 | LeGarret Blount | RAC |
| 2012 | WR | 175 | Doug Baldwin | ARM |
| 2012 | WR | 176 | Devier Posey | GSQ |
| 2012 | WR | 177 | AJ Jenkins | DGK |
| 2012 | WR | 178 | TY Hilton | E4E |
| 2012 | RB | 179 | Bernard Pierce | LCZ |
| 2012 | TE | 180 | Tony Gonzalez | MBB |
| 2012 | WR | 181 | Leonard Hankerson | MBB |
| 2012 | WR | 182 | Marvin Jones | LCZ |
| 2012 | WR | 183 | Danario Alexander | E4E |
| 2012 | TE | 184 | Greg Olsen | DGK |
| 2012 | RB | 185 | Dan Herron | GSQ |
| 2012 | WR | 186 | KeShawn Martin | ARM |
| 2012 | D | 187 | Texans Defense | RAC |
| 2012 | D | 188 | Packers Defense | THR |
| 2012 | QB | 189 | Russel Wilson | DTD |
| 2012 | TK | 190 | Saints K | FVH |
| 2012 | TK | 191 | Patriots K | FVH |
| 2012 | RB | 192 | Joe McKnight | DTD |
| 2012 | TK | 193 | Packers K | THR |
| 2012 | QB | 194 | Tim Tebow | RAC |
| 2012 | RB | 195 | Toby Gerhart | ARM |
| 2012 | TE | 196 | Michael Egnew | GSQ |
| 2012 | D | 197 | Jets D | DGK |
| 2012 | TK | 198 | Lions K | E4E |
| 2012 | QB | 199 | B.J Coleman | LCZ |
| 2012 | TK | 200 | 49ers K | MBB |
| 2012 | D | 201 | Broncos D | MBB |
| 2012 | D | 202 | Seattle D | LCZ |
| 2012 | D | 203 | Eagles D | E4E |
| 2012 | RB | 204 | Mike Goodson | DGK |
| 2012 | D | 205 | Falcons D | GSQ |
| 2012 | WR | 206 | TJ Graham | ARM |
| 2012 | TK | 207 | Vikes K | RAC |
| 2012 | RB | 208 | Jonathon Dwyer | THR |
| 2012 | D | 209 | Bills D | DTD |
| 2012 | D | 210 | Giants D | FVH |
| 2012 | D | 211 | Cowboys D | FVH |
| 2012 | WR | 212 | Ryan Broyles | DTD |
| 2012 | RB | 213 | Felix Jones | THR |
| 2012 | WR | 214 | Greg Childs | RAC |
| 2012 | TK | 215 | Chargers K | ARM |
| 2012 | TK | 216 | Falcons K | GSQ |
| 2012 | WR | 217 | Emmanuel Sanders | DGK |
| 2012 | WR | 218 | Rishard Matthews | E4E |
| 2012 | TK | 219 | Broncos K | LCZ |
| 2012 | WR | 220 | Tommy Streeter | MBB |
| 2012 | RB | 221 | Bilal Powell | MBB |
| 2012 | RB | 222 | Delone Carter | LCZ |
| 2012 | RB | 223 | Vick Ballard | E4E |
| 2012 | TK | 224 | Eagles K | DGK |
| 2012 | WR | 225 | Marvin McNutt | GSQ |
| 2012 | D | 226 | Rams D | ARM |
| 2012 | TK | 227 | Colts K | RAC |
| 2012 | TE | 228 | Dustin Keller | THR |
| 2012 | TK | 229 | Cowboys K | DTD |
| 2012 | WR | 230 | Nate Washington | FVH |
| 2012 | WR | 231 | Laurent Robinson | FVH |
| 2012 | RB | 232 | Evan Royster | DTD |
| 2012 | QB | 233 | Chad Henne | THR |
| 2012 | WR | 234 | Chris Givens | RAC |
| 2012 | TE | 235 | Brent Celek | ARM |
| 2012 | WR | 236 | Travis Benjamin | GSQ |
| 2012 | QB | 237 | Matt Moore | DGK |
| 2012 | RB | 238 | Chris Rainey | E4E |
| 2012 | D | 239 | Titans D | LCZ |
| 2012 | TK | 240 | Bears K | MBB |
| 2012 | RB | 241 | Alex Green | MBB |
| 2012 | TK | 242 | Raiders K | LCZ |
| 2012 | WR | 243 | BJ Cunningham | E4E |
| 2012 | D | 244 | Jaguars D | DGK |
| 2012 | TK | 245 | Rams K | GSQ |
| 2012 | TK | 246 | Texans Kicker | ARM |
| 2012 | WR | 247 | Joe Adams | RAC |
| 2012 | D | 248 | Bengals Defense | THR |
| 2012 | TK | 249 | Giants Kicker | DTD |
| 2012 | RB | 250 | Kevin Smith | FVH |
| 2012 | RB | 251 | Taiwan Jones | FVH |
| 2012 | QB | 252 | Mike Kafka | DTD |
| 2012 | TK | 253 | Cardinals Kicker | THR |
| 2012 | QB | 254 | Kyle Orton | RAC |
| 2012 | WR | 255 | Danny Coale | ARM |
| 2012 | WR | 256 | Randy Moss | GSQ |
| 2012 | TK | 257 | Bucaneers Kicker | DGK |
| 2012 | QB | 258 | Jason Campbell | E4E |
| 2012 | QB | 259 | Shaun Hill | LCZ |
| 2012 | D | 260 | Chiefs Defense | MBB |
TEAMS:
MBB = Meat Jerkin Beef Boys* – Bo
LCZ = Lost Cauz – Nick
E4E = Eight 4 Eight (Meme Kings) – Dart
DGK = Oh, Have Percy!* – Gibby
GSQ = Gone Sqautchin* – Dan
ARM = Armageddons – Isaac
RAC = Rabid Chihuahuas* – Todd
THR = Throwbacks (A Team Has No Name) – Tee
DTD = D-Town’s Dogs – Dalton
FVH = Fiveheads (Quadricorns) – Josh
* Denotes no longer active